Because of teaching commitments here in Chicago I will not be able to join the growing number of young Jesuits, their students, and colleagues at the annual March for Life this weekend. I thought I would use the occasion of the March, however, to address a challenge posed to me nearly a year ago in this blog’s discussion of health care reform: why is it that Catholics—and American Catholics specifically—are so concerned with the issue of abortion? Haven’t the American Catholic bishops in particular allowed themselves to be hijacked by this one issue?
Commonweal board member George Dennis O’Brien argues essentially this point in a new book titled A Catholic Dissent, the content of which one can surmise from the title. In a very different way, Joseph Bottum, editor of the journal First Things, also claims that abortion has become a primary marker of the cultural identity of American Catholics. Even if one agrees with Bottum that the pro-life cause is a significant marker of Catholic identity, it does not follow that it should be so.
The observations of O’Brien and Bottum raise two related questions: first, should opposition to abortion be treated as constitutive of Catholic identity? Is it really that central to our faith? Second, should Catholics make abortion issue number one politically? Should it be prioritized above other issues? I’ll look at the first, more theological question, today and the second in two posts to follow. Read the rest of this entry »