Fish (& chips) on Fridays

Fish Fridays are back for the Catholics of England and Wales, or at least they will be come September.  The bishops conference of those countries announced last week that Friday abstinence from meat will once again become obligatory for their flock starting September 16, the first anniversary of Pope Benedict’s visit to the U.K.

Some sociologists have argued that dropping meatless Fridays in the 1960s was a pastoral error on the Church’s part.  Meatless Fridays, so the thinking goes, were a significant marker of Catholic identity, and the rapid disappearance of so many such markers contributed to the disastrous erosion of Catholic life and practice which began in the late 1960s.

Still, even if one accepts that suddenly dropping an ancient practice such as meatless Fridays was a mistake, it doesn’t necessarily follow that the practice should be revived today.  Nonetheless, it seems to me there are significant theological reasons to praise the bishops of England and Wales for their gutsy decision.  Perhaps we might even learn something from them on this side of the pond.

The first reason I think meatless Fridays are a good idea is that the practice makes Sunday mean more.  Every Sunday we celebrate a little Easter, but Easter can never be separated from Good Friday, so it’s fitting that the remembrance of both days should find expression in our weekly life.  Friday abstinence, in fact, can be seen as a preparation for Sunday’s feast, just as a one-hour fast is preparation for receiving communion.

Our faith involves a whole sacramental economy, not just a 55-minute errand on Sunday morning.  Living a sacramental life means cultivating a way of looking at every aspect of our world as conveying an unseen, divine significance.  Sunday Mass should be the pivot point of our week, and its influence should radiate outward in all the mundane decisions we make throughout our lives, even decisions about what to eat.

My second reason for praising the English and Welsh bishops is that meatless Fridays serve not just to remind us that we are Catholics (giving us a sociological marker of Catholic identity).  They also remind us that doing penance is part of what being Catholic means.  Penance is an act of justice, a way of making right what has been made wrong by our sins.

Of course, not all penance makes the world a better place in a direct or easily quantifiable way, as, say, returning stolen property might do.  But this is because not everything can be made right within the limits of our finite world.  I followed with interest the discussion of Osama bin Laden’s death in Paddy’s post a few weeks ago and the debate about whether or not killing bin Laden could be considered an act of justice.  To my mind, killing bin Laden is almost certainly morally justified, but that’s not quite the same thing as saying it has restored justice.  By even the crudest measure, the scales of justice are still unbalanced:  bin Laden would have to die several thousand deaths before he could be said to “pay for” the evil he has done—and even this would not re-establish justice, would not make right what is wrong, would not bring the innocent back to life.

Justice always remains beyond our human powers to achieve, but that does not make it beyond God’s power to give.  Doing penance, even in as simple a thing as refraining from meat once a week, is a way of reminding ourselves that for true justice we are totally dependent on Christ’s redeeming work on the cross.  Only Jesus can make all things new.  Remembering that is worth doing at least every Friday.

Of course, I know that some will object that giving up meat seems rather arbitrary, that some people actually like fish more than meat, that some will subvert the obligation by ordering fine lobster dinners instead of fish sticks.  It’s always possible for individuals to subvert the spirit of a law while remaining technically within the bounds of the letter, but that’s no reason the rest of us shouldn’t try to remain faithful to both the spirit and the letter.  If the choice of meat seems a bit arbitrary, perhaps that’s because of the necessity of choosing a penance in which everyone can participate.  Since a great part of the value of meatless Fridays is the sense of doing penance together as a Church, the bishops can’t mandate anything so difficult many Catholics wouldn’t be able to do it.  (And besides, one can always give up something more if one wants.)

One final note to skeptics:  I am sure the British bishops have heard some complaints about “turning back the clock,” complaints as predictable as, well, clockwork.  To critics I would argue that this particular practice—refraining from meat once a week—caries a particularly contemporary relevance.  Concerns about the environment, which one hopes are more than a passing trend, have made all of us more conscious of the consequences of unbridled consumption, self-gratification, and unrestrained impulsiveness.  A simple reminder once a week that we should refrain from something good—and tasty!—for the sake of a higher good is a form of Christian witness our world could use quite a bit right now.

So bravo—or, I guess, jolly good!—to our British brethren.



6 Responses to Fish (& chips) on Fridays

  1. Rachel Lu says:

    This is one of those cases of “how lovely to be wrong.” I would never in my life have expected the British bishops — the British bishops!– to be the ones to do this. Amazing! And apparently they’re also restoring the Holy Days of obligation to, well, the Holy Days! Truly, the Holy Spirit remains at work in the Church.

  2. Will Akinson says:

    Hey Anthony S.J.: Why don’t you do research and present us with how fish on fridays (Greek bishops protest of Roman edicts to force meat on fish eating world) became law for Christians back in ancient church history, along with kneeling to royalty at mass became tradition in church (Council of Nicaea forbid kneeling in catholic churches) And while your at it, is chicken, pheasants, crow eating meat after all they are birds, not mammals. And is eating vegie hamburgers forbidden, how about turkey hot dogs. And will I still, like back in 40’s and 50’s be condemmed to HELL if I eat barbequed steak and salmon on my home grill after sundown on friday which is sabbath in ancient world. Where in Gospel does Jesus forbid eating of anything on sunday, or sabbath, Hmmmm seems as if he did just opposite. I suspect wise church leaders got rid of foolish practices for just what they are, stupid, foolish and anti Christ theological political crap….. Makes me wonder if renewing all this stuff is to get parishoners minds off of troubled church abuse stuff going on, hey it worked in America, Bishops got everybody on knees while 20 minutes of communion is going on, in egypt people stand or sit, and community meals and Eucharist is more important than meaty practices or kneeling.

  3. Rachel Lu says:

    One of the delightful things about being Catholic is that it allows us to maintain that Truth is one, unchangeable and eternal, without groaning under the burden of disciplines and regulations that are utterly inappropriate for our time. This is a hard line to walk, as many religions have discovered, but we can do it because we have 1) a carefully nuanced theology, which distinguishes for us the unchangeable truths from the more provisional disciplines, 2) a carefully constructed ecclesiastical hierarchy, which allows for diligent consideration of all the relevant questions, and 3) the guidance of the Holy Spirit. Even with all these blessings, the system doesn’t always function with all the grace and swiftness of a well-oiled machine, and sometimes it seems downright clumsy. Still, all things considered, it’s held together awfully well these past few millennia, and I think we should give it a chance. I don’t know if you’ve ever been anything else besides Catholic, but I have, and let me just say: in terms of arbitrariness of rules, you can do much, much worse. But I think it’s one of those things where you have to make a good-faith effort to stay with the program for awhile; if you’re determined not to let it make sense to you, it never will.

  4. Qualis Rex says:

    Will – I don’t know your agenda (but actually, I think I do) here, but once again, you are highly mistaken on the history of fasting. Rest assured, it is not some “vast Roman conspiracy on the Eastern World” as your historic revisionism would suggest. The act of abstinance from meat on Fridays is found throughout the ancient Christian world – in corners such as the Syriac/Malabar church in India and the Tewahedo church of Ethiopia where those Big Ol’ Roman meanies never got to touch. Incidently, these churches fast on Fridays AND Wednesdays as well as the full 40 days of Lent ANd other holidays; totaling up to 250 days (i.e. more than half the days of the year). And…um…they also kneel and prostrate themselves. Kinda makes everything you wrote a bit…well…false.

    Anton – GREAT post as usual. I wholeheartedly agree with every sentiment you wrote, specifically how difficult the baseline of “common” penance is. I remember an American friend of mine lamenting how many families simply make Friday a “pizza night” instead of “really” fasting (to him pizza was somehow more “fun” than eating fish-sticks). I explained that to many cultures, eating fish is more of a luxury than say, bread, tomato and cheese (the sum of a pizza). So, I think the whole concept of fasting is subjective, varying from culture and social stratum.

    Anyway, you already know my opinion on the subject. But I really would like to add that ANY external sign of our Catholic/Christian identity is welcome, since it could hopefully lead to a further internal meaning.

    It would also be nice to see more people cross themselves before meals. I know in my case it absolutely reminds me to be thankful for the fact I get to put food in my mouth, let alone something I am really looking forward to eating.

  5. Joe Simmons, SJ says:

    Antonino Pio,

    Delighted as always by your post. Delighted further still by your new interest in matters ecological. Have a good Memorial Day, JS sj

  6. Qualis Rex says:

    Antonino Pio?? Hmmm….fits : P

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: